Limitation period for the 2015 tax period
3. After the FTA found in its objection decision of 24 February 2025 that the limitation period had expired for the 2014 tax period, the present dispute concerns only the tax years 2015 to 2021. In the meantime, following the expiry of the ten-year absolute limitation period under Art. 42 para. 6 VAT Act, the right to assess tax has also become time-barred in relation to the 2015 tax period. The appeal must therefore be upheld in respect of the tax still in dispute for that tax year, and the contested decision must be set aside without replacement to that extent.
Basis of assessment
5.1.1. The basis for calculating the service provided by the appellant to its clients must be the asset management fee charged for it (see consid. 4.1.1). The fact that, as part of the service it is contractually obliged to provide, the appellant is required not only to manage its clients’ assets but also to surrender trailer fees does not alter this. It is true that, after deducting the trailer fees owed by the appellant to the client from the “gross” asset management fee, the client ultimately has to pay only an amount reduced by the trailer fees. However, this results solely from setting off the trailer fees against the asset management fee.
No reduction in consideration
5.1.2. The trailer fees have a direct connection with the principal service owed, namely asset management, insofar as they arise only because of the intermediary activity: because the appellant assumes responsibility for managing its clients’ assets, it invests those assets, among other things, in investment funds as part of this activity and is paid for the associated distribution service. It then passes the trailer fees generated in this way on to its clients in accordance with the agreement concluded with them. Even if there may be a certain proportional relationship between the trailer fee and the principal service, unlike rebates or discounts and similarly to credit card commissions, cheque fees, WIR deductions and the like, there is no reduction in consideration, since from an economic perspective the service is not provided by the appellant itself but by a third party, namely the fund management company (see consid. 4.1.4.2 in fine).
Decision
6. These considerations lead to the appeal being partially upheld. The contested decision must be set aside without replacement with regard to value added tax for the 2015 tax period. In all other respects, the appeal must be dismissed.
1. The appeal is partially upheld and the contested decision is set aside with regard to the 2015 tax period. In all other respects, the appeal is dismissed.
Source
Federal Supreme Court judgment 9C_563/2025 of 5 October 2026