Submitted text
The Federal Council is instructed to systematically record and publish the annual development of the catalogue of benefits under compulsory health care insurance (OKP). For this purpose, it shall commission the Federal Commission for Cost and Quality Monitoring (EKKQ). The EKKQ shall identify both new and existing benefits and, where possible, analyse their additional costs as well as additional opportunities in terms of benefits, including potential savings for insured persons and for patients. A minority (Wyss, Crottaz, Gysi Barbara, Marti Samira, Meyer Mattea, Piller Carrard, Porchet, Weichelt) proposes that the motion be rejected.
Rationale
In view of the continuing pressure on costs and premiums, transparency regarding the development of the OKP benefits catalogue should be improved. Rising costs and premiums are easier for the public to understand if it is shown at the same time which additional benefits are being financed and what added health value they provide. Volume growth in existing benefits should also be taken into account in the monitoring. The monitoring could be published annually as part of premium communications. The expansion of the benefits catalogue by Parliament, the Federal Office of Public Health, the Federal Council and the Federal Administrative Court is one of the reasons for the steady growth in costs, which is ultimately reflected in premiums. Cost transfers from other social insurance schemes or from the cantons to the OKP can also be observed. This is precisely why a differentiated presentation would be useful, showing the share of cost growth attributable to new benefits and the share attributable to volume growth in existing benefits. Unlike the related pending or completed proposals, the new benefits and additional costs should be monitored continuously and only to a limited extent retrospectively (a few years), since the effort would hardly be worthwhile, would be methodologically demanding and would unnecessarily tie up administrative resources. The EKKQ can decide which benefits should reasonably be included in this overview. It is important that the origin of the decision be traceable: Parliament, the Federal Office of Public Health, the Federal Council, the Federal Administrative Court, and transfers of burdens from other social insurance schemes and the cantons. The request is not to be understood as a ‘Marschhalt beim Leistungskatalog’ or as criticism of individual benefits; rather, it is intended to improve transparency concerning the relationship between the expansion of benefits, additional costs and additional benefits. Ideally, individual responsibility could be strengthened, as premium payers would have transparent information concerning new and existing benefits. Since the introduction of the Health Insurance Act (KVG), gross OKP benefits per insured person have risen from 1723 francs in 1996 to around 4992 francs in 2025. In 2025, gross OKP benefits amounted to 44.8 billion francs; benefits increased by more than 6 per cent compared with the previous year. This cost trend is directly reflected in premiums. The average premium announced each September rose by 6.6 per cent in 2023, 8.7 per cent in 2024, a further 6.0 per cent in 2025 and another 4.4 per cent in 2026. Premiums will rise by an average of 5.0 per cent in 2027. They have thus increased by around 30 per cent within just 5 years.
Source
Swiss Parliament: 26.4723 – Making the expanding OKP benefits catalogue transparent.