At its last meeting, the Committee agreed to consider the partial revision of the Epidemics Act (25.069). It has now begun its detailed consideration of this extensive bill. So far, the CSSS-N has largely endorsed the decisions of the Council of States. In particular, it confirmed the Council of States’ stricter requirements for determining that there is a particular threat to public health. Accordingly, both the risk of contagion and spread posed by a pathogen, on the one hand, and the severity, frequency and infection fatality rate, on the other, must be ‘significantly’ elevated for a particular threat to public health to be determined (Art. 5a para. 1). By 15 votes to 10, the CSSS-N explicitly stated that these conditions do not have to be met cumulatively. The Committee also rejected restricting the measures that the Confederation may take in a particular situation (Art. 6c). By 14 votes to 11, however, it proposes explicitly stating in a new paragraph 2bis that the Federal Council must regularly examine whether the measures ordered are necessary and proportionate. This is intended to strengthen the transparency and legitimacy of the measures without unnecessarily restricting the Confederation’s ability to act. By 20 votes to 4, the Committee supports the Council of States’ decision to explicitly prohibit cantonal penal provisions for breaches of a possible vaccination requirement in future (Art. 22 para. 4). At the same time, by 15 votes to 8 with 1 abstention, it rejected removing the option of vaccination requirements as a last resort from the Epidemics Act.

By 13 votes to 12, the Committee also supported requiring doctors, rather than health insurers, to report the consumption of antimicrobial substances in the outpatient sector directly (Art. 13a para. 2). It aims thereby to improve data quality. Also by 13 votes to 12, the CSSS-N proposes that certain diagnostic examinations conducted as part of national programmes may be carried out at decentralised locations or together with other institutions even without a laboratory licence (Arts. 16a and 16b para. 1). This is intended to promote services close to patients and low-threshold access to certain tests. By 19 votes to 3 with 1 abstention, the Committee further stipulates that the effects on the mental health of vulnerable persons must be taken into account when cantonal measures are adopted (Art. 31 para. 2bis). Finally, by 15 votes to 8 with 1 abstention, the Committee proposes that persons concerned may be required to provide the authorities with information about their contacts for contact tracing purposes only where there is a particular threat to public health (Art. 33 para. 2). A number of further proposals, aimed in particular at limiting interference with fundamental rights, will be resubmitted for debate in the Council as minority proposals.

The Committee will continue its consideration of the partial revision of the Epidemics Act in the next quarter.